Categories
Mimetic Theory Outsiders The Outside Wild Theory

Preliminary Theory of the In-Group Contrarian

I recently tweeted about the concept of the “in-group contrarian” – a figure on social media who nominally belongs to a given ideological formation but consistently dissents from its orthodoxies. Although the thread didn’t get shared all that widely, it did get some good feedback, including being listed as a “thread of the week” at OneZero. So I’m inaugurating this new blog with an expanded post on the topic.

For background, the terminology I’m using here and in the thread comes from the work of the cultural theorist René Girard. Girard was above all interested in the mimetic, or imitative, aspects of human behavior, a quality we can see illustrated constantly in online spaces. Put simply, the path of least resistance when using a platform like Twitter is to observe what others are doing – what they’re talking about, what they’re sharing – and copy them. Retweeting, liking, and reusing hashtags is easier than composing an original post, and the posts you’re most likely to retweet and like are ones that have already been retweeted and liked by many people. Whenever a tweet is widely shared, we see the “mimetic snowballing” Girard described. This is how these platforms prime us to behave at all times.

(I’ve written more extensively on mimetic structure of digital platforms and on Girard’s surprising link to social media’s origins; if you’re interested in a fuller account of all of this, follow the link.)

So with the basic mimetic patterns of platform behavior in mind, we can see that ideological in-groups are fueled by imitation. We can also see that group identities cohere around moments of mimetic coalescence. The spread of a hashtag is probably the simplest illustration. By repeating the hashtag, you merge with a social formation. When a hashtag trends, the result can be what Émile Durkheim called “collective effervescence.” In Elementary Forms of Religious Life, Durkheim argued that experiences of ecstatic cohesion formed the basis both of religion and of any collective identity.

Girard drew upon Durkheim’s account, but added other dimensions to it. He was interested not just in behavior, but in desire. And for him, desire is never just a desire for things, but a desire for being – that is to say, a desire to fill an inner void by attaching it to something that validates our sense of self. The point is relatively simple to make in the instance I’ve been describing. When people participate in pile-ons, share viral hashtags, and so on, there’s a deeper desire at work: a desire for the reaffirmation of our identity by fusing with a larger group.

We can now return to the concept of the In-Group Contrarian (hereafter IGC). Anyone who has observed social media platforms, especially Twitter, will know the type. This is the person who, precisely when mimetic snowballing is in progress, attempts to apply the brakes. What’s important is that this figure is not simply an outsider to the group, in which case they could probably be ignored, but instead claims to share the group’s goals, beliefs, etc and merely objects to some aspect of this manifestation of them. The appearance of this figure is as predictable as the mimetic snowballing itself.

Of course, the majority of IGCs are low-follower anonymous accounts, and can be simply ignored. But a few IGCs already have, or gain, a certain reputation and a following (more on that in a minute), and become harder to ignore. The reaction to these high-profile IGCs differs from the response to an ideological opponent (out-group member). The latter’s criticisms of one’s group can usually be dismissed. Often, in contrast, the IGC must not just be dismissed, but destroyed. In fact, many in-groups seem to dedicate more time and energy to attacking the IGCs attached to their group than they do to attacking their straight-up enemies. In fact, hatred of the IGC can become one of the main things that binds the in-group together.

This would be a version of the scapegoat effect, central to how Girard modifies Durkheim’s theory of collective effervescence. For Girard, groups only truly coalesce by expelling, or sacrificing, a group member. It is in the act of violent unity against this “surrogate victim” that the group’s collective identity reaches its apotheosis. That’s because whatever antagonisms exist within the group are displaced onto the designated scapegoat. The repudiation of the IGC represents an incomplete version of this operation, because usually s/he never goes away, because the in-group itself can’t fully expel him or her. That’s partly, I would argue, because on some level it doesn’t want to.

It’s easy to observe that the IGC, rather than simply being cast out, often becomes a persistent object of perverse fascination for the in-group. Here too Girard is helpful. The IGC’s objections function as an obstacle to the fulfillment of desire for collective effervescence and self-affirmation in the group. In this way, he or she functions as a skandalon or “stumbling-block,” a term Girard takes from the Bible.

But the relation to the skandalon is more complex than it seems, because it is never simply an obstacle, but an obstacle to which we return again and again, as if addicted to it. We see this when in-group members obsess over and fixate on the IGC. Why? To restate a prior point, if my desire is mimetic, it comes from observing others. I copy my desire from the large mass of similar people I observe engaging in herding behavior together. But then, the IGC transmits a counter-signal that blocks the full movement of desire. As a result, my desire, and the sense of being I obtain from group belonging, is placed in question. The IGC becomes an object of fascination because of the power he or she is capable of exerting on me by attenuating the fulfillment of my desire. But this, in turn, makes the IGC into another potential model – a prospect that throws my sense of self into crisis.

There are two possible results when this has occurred. One, the most numerically likely, is that I remain fully attached to the group, but must periodically, ritualistically cast out the IGC (in sync with the rest of the group) – an act that both conceals and reveals his/her enigmatic effect on me. But in a certain percentage of cases, the IGC will show my desire a different path, and I will follow it. In this way, the IGC can peel off certain in-group members and push them to the outer boundaries of the group. These IGC hangers-on become mimetically attached to the group’s fringe, rather than its orthodox core.

All the incentives at first seem to work against embracing IGC status. Occupying the role of scapegoat, of object of collective rage and repudiation, is not an attractive prospect to most. But to a few persistent gadflies, IGC status can bring dividends. Since platforms prime us for herd behavior, they tend to produce sameness. But at the same time, success in the attention economy necessitates differentiation. Thus, by standing out amidst the mimetic uniformity of the in-group, the IGC can build a following. (Of course, once this following reaches a critical mass, it may display the same tendency to herding as the original in-group.)

One of the ways the in-group attempts to cast out the IGC is to call him or her a “grifter.” In some sense, it may be true that some IGCs have recognized the pattern I’m describing – specifically, the way that dissent from the herding dynamics can be an effective way to game the attention economy – and are exploiting it consciously. But of course, plenty of in-group members in good standing reap far greater dividends (both socially and monetarily) from reinforcing orthodoxy. These are simply two attention economy self-marketing strategies, and it’s unclear why only one should be demeaned as a “grift.”

Beneath the antagonism, there is a symbiosis between the in-group and the IGC formations that crop up around its edges. To return to a prior point, as IGCs appear and gather followings, the in-group will increasingly define itself in opposition to these fringe figures – again, often more so than against their nominal ideological enemies. So, paradoxically, even as the IGC functions as an obstacle to the in-group’s fantasy of full mimetic apotheosis, the in-group also needs the IGC’s antagonistic presence to consolidate itself against. This, again, is a kind of half-realized scapegoat effect: the in-group maintains the IGC as a reserve of sacrificial victims whose presence can be invoked in order to reconsolidate group identity. Conversely, of course, the IGC’s project is premised on the continued existence of the in-group.

You will likely have a sense of where you fall in the orbit of the group(s) you affiliate with: closer to the core or closer to the fringes of some formation. Your feelings about IGCs will probably depend to some extent on this. But from the systemic perspective I am attempting to outline, there is no point in decrying “contrarians” – or in seeing them as essential. They are a component of a self-regulating cybernetic mechanism. You, too, are part of this mechanism.

127 replies on “Preliminary Theory of the In-Group Contrarian”

I understand ‘grifter’ in its older, colloquial sense as a con artist or huckster, someone seeking self-advancement who has little regard for the truth or the damage he causes. So by extension a grifter is essentially a yuppie, a careerist. In other words the grifter isn’t simply interested in the thin wages of the attention economy but in real material gains at the expense of other people. Apparently the term has gone the way of ‘gaslight’– i.e., any speaker/speech act contradicting my own. It’s notable though that both of these ubiquitous terms stress the fundamental unreliability of motive and communication on the internet.

I feel like the In-Group Contrarian typically isn’t actually a member of the group, they’re a member of a different group entirely and they’ve just taken on the local color to fit in.

It used to be that the IGC in question would never get any support or reinforcement for a dissenting view; everyone around them would hold the majority position, and the IGC would stay silent simply to maintain their social group. But with the internet, the IGC can find the group they’re *actually* a member of, and find social fulfillment in that group, and not have to pretend to views and attitudes they don’t hold simply to have someone to talk to.

So they aren’t so much being Contrarian, as simply declaring that they’re No Longer Part Of The Group.

there is an underlying issue here. Who is the contrarian copying? Mimesis must also deal with genesis. In group contrarians are not necessarily taking a contrarian stance directly but as a side effect of original thought. most contrarians respond to the contradictions of an in-group idea. it is not contrarianism to the group that drives the behavior, the contrarian behavior is an effect resulting from an original analysis of content.

YOU NEED HELP FOR SEO LINK BUILDING?

We offer you the BEST SEO STRATEGY for 2020, my name is Abe Arispe, and I’m a SEO Specialist.

I just checked out your website outsidertheory.com, and wanted to find out if you need help for SEO Link Building ?

Build unlimited number of Backlinks and increase Traffic to your websites which will lead to a higher number of customers and much more sales for you.

SEE FOR YOURSELF=> https://bit.ly/3dhrKtA

Great blog you have here but I was wanting to know if you knew of any
discussion boards that cover the same topics discussed in this article?
I’d really like to be a part of community where I can get feedback from other knowledgeable individuals that share the same interest.
If you have any recommendations, please let me know. Thanks!

Also visit my web page :: CBD Relive Reviews

What i do not realize is actually how you’re not really
a lot more well-favored than you might be right now. You are so
intelligent. You know therefore considerably in the case of this subject,
made me personally believe it from so many numerous angles.
Its like men and women don’t seem to be fascinated except
it is one thing to accomplish with Girl gaga! Your individual stuffs excellent.
At all times deal with it up!

Feel free to surf to my page :: Watt Pro Saver Price

Hiya! Quick question that’s totally off topic. Do you know
how to make your site mobile friendly? My web site
looks weird when viewing from my iphone 4. I’m trying to find
a template or plugin that might be able to correct this problem.
If you have any recommendations, please share. Thanks!

Also visit my web blog … Shark Lean Reviews

This design is steller! You most certainly know how to keep a reader
amused. Between your wit and your videos, I was
almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Excellent job.
I really enjoyed what you had to say, and more than that,
how you presented it. Too cool!

my homepage; Bone + Oak Keto

This is the perfect blog for anybody who wishes to understand this topic.
You know a whole lot its almost tough to argue with you (not that I really
would want to?HaHa). You certainly put a brand new spin on a subject that’s been written about for
ages. Great stuff, just wonderful!

Also visit my website … Biosource Wellness Keto

It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d certainly donate to this superb blog!
I guess for now i’ll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my
Google account. I look forward to fresh updates and will share this website with
my Facebook group. Chat soon!

Here is my blog; Premier ME

May I simply say what a comfort to uncover somebody
that truly knows what they’re discussing on the net. You definitely
know how to bring a problem to light and make it important.
More and more people ought to read this and understand this
side of your story. I can’t believe you aren’t
more popular because you surely have the gift.

Check out my blog post Bio Gold CBD Reviews

I would like to express appreciation to this writer just for bailing me out
of such a problem. Because of browsing throughout the online world and obtaining methods which were not pleasant, I
was thinking my life was done. Being alive without
the presence of approaches to the issues you’ve solved by way of your
good guide is a critical case, and the kind which may have negatively affected my entire career if
I hadn’t come across your web page. Your good know-how and kindness in maneuvering everything was precious.
I am not sure what I would have done if I had not encountered such a
subject like this. I can also now look forward to my future.

Thanks for your time so much for your professional and effective guide.
I won’t be reluctant to endorse the blog to any individual
who needs and wants care about this topic.

Here is my web blog … Rize Male Enhancement Review

I and my friends ended up reading through the good suggestions on the blog and before long got a terrible suspicion I had not expressed respect to you for
those techniques. Most of the people were definitely so warmed to read
them and have very much been taking pleasure in these things.
We appreciate you genuinely well kind and then for opting
for certain amazing areas millions of individuals are really needing to discover.
My personal sincere apologies for not expressing appreciation to
sooner.

Feel free to visit my blog post :: http://nulavance.org/

I would like to use the chance of saying thanks
to you for that professional direction I have continually enjoyed checking out your site.
I’m looking forward to the actual commencement of
my school research and the general preparation would never have been complete without consulting your web blog.
If I may be of any assistance to others, I’d be thankful to help
by what I have discovered from here.

Also visit my site … http://mysticstylecream.com/

We would like to thank you all over again for the beautiful ideas you gave
Jeremy when preparing her post-graduate research as well
as, most importantly, pertaining to providing
each of the ideas in a blog post. Provided that we had known of your site a year ago,
we would have been rescued from the unnecessary measures we were choosing.
Thank you very much.

my site – Ascension Keto Pills

I have been exploring for a little for any high quality articles or blog posts
on this sort of area . Exploring in Yahoo I finally stumbled upon this site.

Studying this information So i am happy to show
that I have an incredibly excellent uncanny feeling I came upon just what I
needed. I so much undoubtedly will make sure to don?t
disregard this website and give it a glance on a continuing basis.

Also visit my site … DermaFil Anti Aging Cream

I actually wanted to make a simple message so as to
express gratitude to you for all the fantastic
guidelines you are placing at this website. My prolonged internet look up has at the end been recognized with really good concept to exchange with my
two friends. I ‘d suppose that we readers actually are definitely endowed to live in a magnificent community with so many awesome people with very helpful basics.

I feel really grateful to have used your entire web page and look forward to plenty of more awesome times reading here.
Thanks a lot again for a lot of things.

Feel free to surf to my homepage; Mystic Style Anti Aging Serum

Hi! I know this is somewhat off-topic but I had to ask.
Does operating a well-established website such as yours require a
massive amount work? I am brand new to running a
blog however I do write in my journal every day. I’d like to start a blog
so I can easily share my own experience and thoughts online.
Please let me know if you have any recommendations or tips for new aspiring blog owners.
Thankyou!

Also visit my web-site: Mystic Style Serum Reviews

Fantastic blog you have here but I was curious if you knew of any
community forums that cover the same topics talked about here?
I’d really love to be a part of online community
where I can get comments from other knowledgeable individuals that share the same interest.
If you have any recommendations, please let me know. Appreciate it!

Check out my blog post; http://blauxwearableac.net/

Thank you so much for providing individuals with remarkably breathtaking opportunity to
read in detail from this web site. It’s usually so good and full of a good time for me personally and my office
co-workers to search your blog more than three times every week to read the fresh guides
you will have. And definitely, I’m always happy with your breathtaking creative ideas you give.
Selected 1 ideas in this article are clearly the most beneficial we have all had.

Here is my page :: Pulsar Earbuds

Hi there I am so delighted I found your weblog, I really found you
by accident, while I was researching on Digg for something else, Nonetheless I am here now and
would just like to say kudos for a incredible post and a all round interesting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don?t have time to browse it all at the minute but I have book-marked it and also included your RSS feeds,
so when I have time I will be back to read more, Please do keep up the great b.

Feel free to surf to my website; http://megaxxlmaleenhancement.com/

Hmm it seems like your website ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I guess
I’ll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your
blog. I as well am an aspiring blog writer but I’m still new to the whole thing.
Do you have any points for beginner blog writers?
I’d genuinely appreciate it.

Here is my webpage – Macro Keto

I’m writing to let you be aware of what a superb encounter
my cousin’s child undergone browsing your webblog. She mastered numerous pieces, which included what it is like to possess a very effective coaching style
to get folks without problems know a variety of extremely tough topics.
You really exceeded readers’ expected results. Thank you for rendering these
useful, trustworthy, informative not to mention unique tips about your topic to Lizeth.

Here is my blog :: Novum Health Keto

Attractive element of content. I just stumbled upon your website and in accession capital to claim that I acquire in fact
enjoyed account your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing on your feeds or even I success you get admission to persistently quickly.

my web page; Beau Serum Review

Hi there would you mind sharing which blog platform you’re working with?
I’m going to start my own blog in the near future but I’m having a difficult time making a decision between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal.
The reason I ask is because your layout seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something completely unique.
P.S Sorry for getting off-topic but I had to ask!

Feel free to visit my web site KetoFab Review

Comments are closed.